In the world of football, few topics stir as much debate as the potential transfer of a star player. Liverpool's Andy Robertson is currently at the heart of such discussions.
Robertson has been a mainstay of the Reds defence since his arrival from Hull City in 2017 for an initial fee of just £8 million ($10.9 million). He has played just under 300 games in all competitions for the club and won every trophy going under the auspices of Jurgen Klopp.
Now, with Klopp having left at the end of last season and a new era beginning under Arne Slot, there is a suggestion that Robertson's best days could be behind him.
With opinions divided on his future at the club, fans and analysts alike are pondering whether the Liverpool should keep or sell the 30-year-old left-back.
MORE: The tactics, playing style, and trophies won by Liverpool manager Arne Slot
Does Andy Robertson still have a big role to play at Liverpool?
Andy Robertson has been a cornerstone of Liverpool's defense since his arrival. His relentless energy and pinpoint crosses have made him a fan favorite and a key player. However, as he approaches 31, questions about his form and fitness are becoming more pressing.
Dave Hendrick from the Anfield Index podcast didn't hold back in his assessment.
"He would be very high on my list to sell. We've seen significant decline and an uptick of injuries over recent years, and he is a big part of the unbalance of our team."
These comments highlight the challenges Robertson faces as he ages, especially in a demanding role like left-back.
Hendrick also pointed out a tactical shift that might be influencing this viewpoint:
"We look better with Joe Gomez at left-back as he's a much stronger defender and doesn't spend most of the game playing as a winger."
This suggests that Liverpool could benefit from a more defensively solid option at left-back, particularly in high-stakes matches.
All the latest EPL club news | Team-by-team Premier League schedule for 2024/25 | Latest Premier League top scorer rankings
Is Andy Robertson good enough to keep up with a tactical evolution?
Football tactics evolve constantly, and Liverpool's strategy is no exception. Hendrick's analysis hints at a broader tactical shift to come under Slot:
"If we're wanting to improve this side, left-back is one of the easiest positions to upgrade and I can't see him sticking around to be a back-up."
This suggests Liverpool's management could be considering changes. The Reds are not usually shy when it comes to adapting to the demands of modern football, where flexibility and endurance are crucial.
Robertson's contract, expiring in June 2026, adds urgency to making a decision. Hendrick further noted:
"He's 31 next summer, with just two years left on his contract, so I really struggle to see [football CEO] Michael Edwards giving him a new contract."
The financial implications of letting high-wage players leave for free are significant. Hendrick emphasized:
"The era of letting players leave for free needs to end, so I would be looking to sell him this summer."
What is the market value of Andy Robertson?
The transfer market is unpredictable but offers opportunities for clubs to refresh their squads. Hendrick's valuation of Robertson reflects a practical approach:
"If someone came in with £18-20 million ($23.2-25.8 million), I would snap it straight up."
Considering Robertson's age and recent form, this seems reasonable and aligns with current market trends.
Speculation about potential destinations adds another layer to this discussion. Hendrick suggested:
"For me, it would be a sell. I think he would go to Bayern Munich."
A move to a club like Bayern could benefit both Robertson and Liverpool, offering the player a new challenge and the club a chance to reinvest in younger talent.
Andy Robertson: A Liverpool legend but time for change?
Ending on a note of recognition, Hendrick acknowledged Robertson's contributions:
"He's been an incredible servant and the best pound-for-pound signing we've made since [Alan] Hansen, but I don't think we can afford to be sentimental right now."
This attitude highlights the tough nature of professional sports, where strategic and financial imperatives often take precedence over sentiment.
While Robertson's legacy at Liverpool is secure, his future may lie elsewhere. As the club attempts to remain at the forefront of modern football, decisions like this, however difficult, are necessary.
It's a reminder of the delicate balance between respecting past contributions and meeting future needs in football management.
