It's the issue that has overshadowed New South Wales' first State of Origin series win since 2014, and Blues coach Brad Fittler is still none the wiser about how Billy Slater was awarded the Wally Lewis Medal.
Slater was the surprise recipient of the award after being named man of the match in Queensland's game three victory.
The entire rugby league world went into meltdown after the decision was announced, with many believing Damien Cook, James Tedesco or Tom Trbojevic were more worthy recipients.
At the heart of the matter was that Slater didn't even play in game one.
MORE: Selectors choose Slater over Tedesco | Barrett demands clarification from referees
He was influential upon his return from injury in game two, and played well in game three, but most viewers felt Daly Cherry-Evans was the best Maroon on the field.
Darren Lockyer, Mal Meninga and Laurie Daley were the men in charge of naming the Wally Lewis Medal winner, with points given on a 4-3-2-1 basis for each game of the series.
Lockyer said it wasn't even a close count, with Slater the obvious choice.
Speaking on the Footy Show on Sunday morning, Fittler said he had no idea how Slater would have claimed so many points in game two.
"I couldn't understand the points," he said.
"I couldn't understand why Billy was so far ahead in the points.
"I think he had a great game, and I thought his start of the game was excellent - he really got them on the front foot and gave them the zip they needed.
"But to not nail the end, I just couldn't understand why he got so many points in game two that put him so far ahead.
"That's what I couldn't understand."
