AFL trade news: Who wins the Steven May deal, Melbourne or Gold Coast?

Sporting News

AFL trade news: Who wins the Steven May deal, Melbourne or Gold Coast? image

After Jesse Hogan was traded to Melbourne for picks 6 and 23, Melbourne used their first-round selection to make a deal with Gold Coast for Steven May.

The Player

Steven May

Date of birth: 10/1/92 (27 at round one 2019)

Games: 123

The Deal

Melbourne

In: Steven May and Kade Kolodjashnij

Out: Pick 6

Gold Coast

In: Pick 6

Out: Steven May and Kade Kolodjashnij

The needs

Melbourne Demons

The list at Melbourne has been well constructed and is strong all over the ground, but the 2018 campaign left the Demons feeling they needed a better key defender than the current options, Oscar McDonald and Sam Frost. There’s no doubt Steven May is one of the best in the business, but there’s a certain feeling of over-capitalising, especially when you add the seemingly forgotten Jake Lever to the list of big backmen. Still, they got the man they wanted and his presence will free up some of his new teammates while simultaneously scaring the crap out of opponents with a physicality not usually associated with Melbourne sides.

Gold Coast Suns

et’s face it, the Suns only need was to keep their captain on the Gold Coast. In any other trade situation it would be reasonable to say this was a fair deal – a top-five selection for a 27-year-old defender – but the worry is whoever the Suns select with that pick will be on their bike two years from now.

The winner

It doesn’t even matter if Melbourne needs Steven May or not, this is at least a break-even deal for the Demons. For the Suns it’s a big loss. The winner is Melbourne.

Sporting News

Sporting News Photo

The sports world explained. The Sporting News goes beyond the score to deliver the news, data, insights and entertainment that sports fans around the globe need to know.