James Sicily AFL Tribunal result: Hawthorn captain successfully contests kicking charge

Kieran Francis

James Sicily AFL Tribunal result: Hawthorn captain successfully contests kicking charge image

Hawthorn star James Sicily fronted the AFL Tribunal on Tuesday night to contest a suspension for kicking.

He was ultimately successful, with his one-match ban downgraded to a fine.

The Hawks skipper initially copped a one-match suspension for making contact with his leg to the body of Essendon player Andrew McGrath.

The Sporting News has the latest.

MOREFollow the Coleman Medal race with daily updates | Every fixture and result for the 2024 AFL season | Every AFL team’s injury list and Supercoach implications

What was Hawthorn's appeal at the AFL Tribunal?

The Hawks argued that the impact should be graded as low, not medium.

The panel agreed, with Tribunal chairman Jeff Gleeson stating the risk of injury from the kick was "relatively low".

Sicily did plead guilty to the charge and was fined $2500, rather than picking up a suspension.

Why was James Sicily at the AFL Tribunal?

After giving away a free kick to Bombers utility Matt Guelfi in Round 1, Sicily was involved in a fracas with several Essendon players.

During the incident, Sicily's boot appeared to come into contact with the back of McGrath's legs as the Hawthorn defender pushed his opponent to the ground.

The incident was cited by the AFL Match Review Officer, who graded it as intentional conduct, medium impact and body contact, which equates to a one-match ban.

While speaking to SEN on Monday, McGrath stated he thought the incident was minor and he hoped Sicily's suspension would be overturned.

"After every incident, our club doctor calls us to see if there are any medical ramifications or any soreness, my report to him was that there's nothing – I've got no bruise, no nothing," McGrath said.

"Hopefully that stands up in the appeal, if there is one.

"It was pretty innocuous ... I didn't even really realise that he put his foot into the back of me, which suggests how severe the kick was. Not very at all.

"But they're stamping that out of the game and we'll see where that lands."

Kieran Francis

Kieran Francis Photo

Kieran Francis is a senior editor at The Sporting News based in Melbourne, Australia. He started at Sportal.com.au before being a part of the transition to Sporting News in 2015. Just prior to the 2018 World Cup, he was appointed chief editor of Goal.com in Australia. He has now returned to The Sporting News where his passions lay in football, AFL, poker and cricket - when he is not on holiday.