AFL Best and Fairest winners 2024: Every club champion and top 10 leaderboard

Tom Naghten

AFL Best and Fairest winners 2024: Every club champion and top 10 leaderboard image

With the AFL season now in the books, clubs have been celebrating the individual efforts throughout the year.

Established stars, rising youngsters and unheralded clubmen have all been honoured in 2024.

The Sporting News reveals every best and fairest winner and leaderboard for each club.

AFL Best and Fairest 2024 winners and leaderboards

Adelaide - Malcolm Blight Medal

For the first time in club history, Adelaide had two players share their best and fairest award, with first-time winner Ben Keays joining skipper Jordan Dawson, who claimed his second consecutive club champion honour.

Third-year midfielder Jake Soligo rounded out the top three.

Leaderboard

RankingPlayerVotes
=1st Ben Keays
Jordan Dawson
107
3rdJake Soligo93
4thMax Michalanney89
4thDarcy Fogarty87
6thRory Laird82
7thJosh Rachele79
=8thIzak Rankine
Matt Crouch
72
10thLachlan Sholl69

How voting works

Adelaide’s Club Champion Award is calculated by coaches rating every player with a score from 1-10 after every game this season.

Last five winners

2023Jordan Dawson
2022Rory Laird
2021Rory Laird
2020Reilly O'Brien
2019Brad Crouch

Brisbane - Merrett-Murray Medal

Lachie Neale picked up the fourth Merrett-Murray Medal of his career.

He edged out Dayne Zorko and Josh Dunkley in a narrow vote count.

Leaderboard

RankingPlayerVotes
1st Lachie Neale73
2ndDayne Zorko72
3rdJosh Dunkley71
4thHugh McCluggage64
5thDarcy Wilmot61
6thRyan Lester60
=7thHarris Andrews
Jarrod Berry
Joe Daniher
56
=10thOscar McInerney
Cam Rayner
54

How voting works

The Brisbane coaching staff assess a player's overall performance, influence on the game, team contribution and compliance with team values, with a maximum score of 12.

Past five winners

2023Harris Andrews
2022Lachie Neale
2021Dayne Zorko
2020Lachie Neale
2019Lachie Neale

Carlton - John Nicholls Medal

Fresh off being awarded the 2024 Brownlow Medal, Patrick Cripps claimed his fifth John Nicholls Medal as Carlton's best and fairest.

The captain finished well clear of the chasing pack, led by Nic Newman and Sam Walsh.

Leaderboard

RankingPlayerVotes
1st Patrick Cripps204
2ndNic Newman148
3rdSam Walsh147
4thJacob Weitering144
5thGeorge Hewett141
6thBlake Acres122
7thTom De Koning121
8thHarry McKay117
9thCharlie Curnow116
10thMatthew Kennedy110

How voting works

The John Nicholls Medal is voted on by senior coach Michael Voss and three assistants giving each player up to four votes at the end of every round, meaning a maximum of 16 votes is awarded to any single player per round.

Past five winners

2023Jacob Weitering
2022Patrick Cripps
2021Sam Walsh
2020Jacob Weitering
2019Patrick Cripps

Collingwood - E. W. Copeland Trophy

Nick Daicos has won his first E.W. Copeland Trophy, following in the footsteps of his brother Josh and father Peter.

The Daicos family become the only father and two sons to have all won their club’s best and fairest award.

Leaderboard

RankingPlayerVotes
1st Nick Daicos997
2ndDarcy Cameron859
3rdJosh Daicos741
4thJack Crisp740
5thSteele Sidebottom719
6thScott Pendlebury682
7thPatrick Lipinski656
=8thBobby Hill
Brayden Maynard
645
10thDarcy Moore632

How voting works

The five-member coaching panel award up to 22 votes per game, with no specific distribution or maximum number a single player can be awarded.

Past five winners

2023Josh Daicos
2022Jack Crisp
2021Jack Crisp
2020Taylor Adams
2019Brodie Grundy

Essendon - Crichton Medal

Bombers captain Zach Merrett has collected his fifth Crichton Medal.

He finished ahead of Nic Martin and Sam Durham. 

Leaderboard

RankingPlayerVotes
1st Zach Merrett212
2ndNic Martin197
3rdSam Durham184
4thAndrew McGrath157
5thJye Caldwell154
6thBen McKay151
7thKyle Langford131
8thMason Redman108
9thJake Stringer104
10thHarrison Jones80

How voting works

The voting system consists of five coaches, giving each player a ranking from zero to five after each match. Players can receive a maximum of 25 votes for a game

Past five winners

2023Zach Merrett
2022Peter Wright
2021Zach Merrett
2020Jordan Ridley
2019Zach Merrett

Fremantle - Doig Medal

Fremantle has named star midfielder Caleb Serong its 2024 Doig Medallist for the second year in a row.

Serong beat out 2022 winner Andrew Brayshaw in a season which culminated in a heart-breaking top eight miss for the Dockers.

Leaderboard

RankingPlayerVotes
1stCaleb Serong240
2ndAndrew Brayshaw231
3rdHayden Young200
4thJosh Treacy185
5thSam Switkowski & Jordan Clark168
7thLuke Ryan154
8thAlex Pearce144
9thLuke Jackson130
10thBrandon Walker118
Caleb Serong
(Getty Images)

How voting works

From Fremantle in 2022, "Following each game, Senior Coach Justin Longmuir and four coaches – Josh Carr, Matthew Boyd, Jaymie Graham and Joel Corey – allocated up to five votes to each player based on how they performed their role, meaning a player can receive up to 25 votes in a game for an elite performance."

Past five winners

2023Caleb Serong
2022Andrew Brayshaw
2021Sean Darcy
2020Luke Ryan
2019Nat Fyfe

Geelong - Carji Greeves Medal

Max Holmes was awarded his first Carji Greeves Medal by Geelong.

He polled comfortably ahead of Zach Guthrie and Jeremy Cameron.

Leaderboard

RankingPlayerVotes
1st Max Holmes164
2ndZach Guthrie120
3rdJeremy Cameron118
4thTom Stewart117
5thTyson Stengle107
6thGryan Miers95
7thOllie Dempsey73
8thOllie Henry69
9thBrad Close66
10thPatrick Dangerfield65

How voting works

After each game, the Senior and assistant coaches review and rate each players performance out of 10. Votes are polled in games where a player's performance has been deemed of a high quality by the coaching group. And unlike previous seasons, all matches are counted towards their final total.

Past five winners

2023Tom Stewart
2022Jeremy Cameron, Cameron Guthrie
2021Tom Stewart
2020Cameron Guthrie
2019Patrick Dangerfield

Gold Coast - Club Champion

Key defender Sam Collins added the 2024 Club Champion gong to his triumph in 2020 following yet another standout season.

Collins finished 12 votes ahead of impressive youngster Bodhi Uwland in second.

Leaderboard:

RankingPlayerVotes
1st Sam Collins68
2ndBodhi Uwland56
3rdSam Flanders55
4thMatt Rowell54
5thNoah Anderson50
6thMac Andrew49
7thWil Powell43
8thBen Long39
9thTouk Miller36
10thJarrod Witts35

How voting works

The Suns match committee rates every player from 0-5 after each game.

Last five winners

2023Noah Anderson
2022Touk Miller
2021Touk Miller
2020Sam Collins
2019Jarrod Witts
2018Jarrod Harbrow

GWS - Kevin Sheedy Medal

Coleman Medal winner Jesse Hogan took out the Giants' best and fairest award for 2024.

He edged out Tom Green and Lachie Whitfield by a single point.

Leaderboard

RankingPlayerVotes
1st Jesse Hogan67
=2ndTom Green
Lachie Whitfield
66
4thConnor Idun59
5thBrent Daniels50
6thJack Buckley49
7thToby Greene45
=8thToby Bedford
Harry Perryman
41
10thHarry Himmelberg40

How voting works

Per GWS Giants: Under a new voting system this season, line coaches rated their respective players after each game from a pre-determined performance scale.

All line coaches then met to determine an overall rating for each player before submitting to head coach Adam Kingsley who allocated up to six (6) votes for each player.

Last five winners

2023Toby Greene
2022Sam Taylor
2021Josh Kelly
2020Nick Haynes and Lachie Whitfield
2019Tim Taranto

Hawthorn - Peter Crimmins Medal

Hard-nosed midfielder Jai Newcombe became a first-time winner of the Peter Crimmins Medal, leading from the front in an impressive season for the Hawks.

Newcombe finished nine votes ahead of Dylan Moore in second.

Leaderboard

RankingPlayerVotes
1st Jai Newcombe155
2ndDylan Moore146
3rdJarman Impey119
4thJames Worpel116
4thBlake Hardwick114
6thConnor Macdonald113
7thKarl Amon110
8thJack Scrimshaw108
9thJack Ginnivan107
10thMassimo D'Ambrosio101

How voting works

Six coaches confer to award players up to 12 votes per match.

Last five winners

2023Will Day
2022James Sicily
2021Tom Mitchell
2020Jack Gunston
2019James Worpel

Melbourne - Keith 'Bluey' Truscott Trophy

Jack Viney claimed his second Keith ‘Bluey’ Truscott Memorial Trophy. 

He finished narrowly ahead of Max Gawn and Alex Neal-Bullen.

Leaderboard

RankingPlayerVotes
1st Jack Viney407
2ndMax Gawn405
3rdAlex Neal-Bullen402
4thKysaiah Pickett369
5thEd Langdon352
6thTrent Rivers350
7thJudd McVee347
8thKade Chandler337
9thSteven May316
10thTom McDonald301

How voting works

Four members of the match committee each give every player a rating out of 10, meaning a maximum score of 40 is available in a single game.

Last five winners

2023Christian Petracca
2022Clayton Oliver
2021Clayton Oliver
2020Christian Petracca
2019Clayton Oliver/Max Gawn

North Melbourne - Syd Barker Medal

Powerful midfielder Luke Davies-Uniacke collected a maiden North Melbourne best and fairest on the back of another impressive campaign.

Breakout ruckman Tristan Xerri finished in second, 13 votes back.

Leaderboard

RankingPlayerVotes
1st Luke Davies-Uniacke242
2ndTristan Xerri229
3rdHarry Sheezel212
4thPaul Curtis140
5thTom Powell139
6thCameron Zurhaar129
7thCharlie Comben126
8thAidan Corr125
9thLuke McDonald124
10thJackson Archer115
Luke Davies-Uniacke
(Getty Images)

How voting works

Five coaches rate each player's performance on a 4-3-2-1 system, meaning a player can poll a maximum of 20 votes in a single game.

Last five winners

2023Harry Sheezel
2022Jy Simpkin
2021Jy Simpkin
2020Luke McDonald
2019Ben Cunnington

Port Adelaide - John Cahill Medal

Zak Butters made it two consecutive John Cahill Medals following a season which saw Port Adelaide finish second spot.

Butters finished ahead of rising midfielder Jason Horne-Francis in second. 

Leaderboard

RankingPlayerVotes
1st Zak Butters159
2ndJason Horne-Francis152
3rdAliir Aliir129
4thConnor Rozee118
5thDan Houston117
6thWillem Drew115
7thDarcy Byrne-Jones
Brandon Zerk-Thatcher
112
9thMiles Bergman103
10thOllie Wines93

How voting works

Voting system: N/A

Last five winners

2023Zak Butters
2022Connor Rozee
2021Ollie Wines
2020Darcy Byrne-Jones
2019Travis Boak

Richmond - Jack Dyer Medal

Three-time premiership winner Daniel Rioli has won his first Jack Dyer Medal, in what looks set to be his final season at the club.

Having been converted from a small forward to a rebounding defender, Rioli took home the honour from Nick Vlastuin in second.

Leaderboard

RankingPlayerVotes
1st Daniel Rioli40
2ndNick Vlastuin38
3rdToby Nankervis36
4thNathan Broad33
=5thShai Bolton
Liam Baker
30
7thRhyan Mansell29
8thJayden Short26
9thBen Miller25
10thDion Prestia24

How voting works

Voting system: the match committee gives players a rating from 0-5 based on their overall match performance, taking into account offensive, defensive and contest impacts.

Last five winners

2023Tim Taranto
2022Tom Lynch
2021Dylan Grimes
2020Jayden Short
2019Dion Prestia

St Kilda - Trevor Barker Award

Key defender Callum Wilkie earned his first Trevor Barker Medal following yet another consistent season down back for the Saints.

The 28-year-old hasn't missed a game since his debut in round 1, 2019 and, after earning All Australian selection last year, took out St Kilda's top honour ahead of Jack Sinclair in second.

Leaderboard

RankingPlayerVotes
1st Callum Wilkie206
2ndJack Sinclair174
3rdJosh Battle161
4thRowan Marshall143
5thNasian Wanganeen-Milera133
6thJack Steele122
7thJack Higgins108
8thDarcy Wilson99
9thMitch Owens84
10thBradley Hill72

How voting works

Five coaches give a score from one to four after each match, with players being able to receive a maximum of 20 votes per game.

Last five winners

2023Jack Sinclair
2022Jack Sinclair
2021Jack Steele
2020Jack Steele
2019Seb Ross

Sydney - Bob Skilton Medal

Isaac Heeney won the Bob Skilton Medal following an impressive season for the Swans.

Fellow All-Australians Errol Gulden and Chad Warner rounded out the podium.

Leaderboard

RankingPlayerVotes
1st Isaac Heeney956
2ndErrol Gulden888
3rdChad Warner813
4thBrodie Grundy750
5thNick Blakey648
6thJames Rowbottom639
7thOliver Florent628
8thJames Jordon622
9thJake Lloyd605
10thTom Papley576

Last five winners

2023Errol Gulden
2022Callum Mills
2021Luke Parker
2020Jake Lloyd
2019Dane Rampe

How voting works

Club Champion votes are awarded by the coaching staff. A player can be awarded a maximum of 50 votes per game, and coaches can allocate up to 10 votes for as many or as few players as they deem appropriate, per match.

West Coast - John Worsfold Medal

Key defender Jeremy McGovern collected the first John Worsfold medal of his career in 2024, adding to an already decorated career.

McGovern edged out experienced midfielder Elliot Yeo by seven votes to take out the award.

Leaderboard

RankingPlayerVotes
1st Jeremy McGovern184
2ndElliot Yeo177
3rdJake Waterman155
4thLiam Duggan141
5thBrady Hough136
6thJamie Cripps127
7thTom Barrass122
8thTom Cole117
9thHarley Reid114
10thTim Kelly112
Jeremy McGovern
(Getty Images)

How voting works

Each member of the five-person match committee rates every player on a scale of 0-3 after each match.

Last five winners

2023Tim Kelly
2022Tom Barrass
2021Nic Naitanui
2020Nic Naitanui
2019Luke Shuey

Western Bulldogs - Charles Sutton Medal

Marcus Bontempelli won his sixth Charles Sutton Medal at the Bulldogs' end of season awards.

He finished comfortably ahead of Adam Treloar and Bailey Dale, who were tied for second.

Leaderboard

RankingPlayerVotes
1st Marcus Bontempelli314
=2ndAdam Treloar
Bailey Dale
245
4thLiam Jones203
5thEd Richards188
6thTom Liberatore 170
7thLachlan Bramble168
8thRory Lobb163
9thBailey Williams161
10thTaylor Duryea152

How voting works

Each member of the five-person match committee rates every player on a scale of 0-5 after each match.

Last five winners

2023Marcus Bontempelli
2022Josh Dunkley
2021Marcus Bontempelli
2020Caleb Daniel
2019Marcus Bontempelli

Tom Naghten

Tom Naghten Photo

Tom Naghten is a senior editor at The Sporting News Australia where he's been part of the team since 2017. He predominantly covers boxing and MMA. In his spare time, he likes to watch Robbie Ahmat's goal against the Kangaroos at the SCG in 2000.